Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts

Tuesday, 27 March 2012

Don't Think About Batman, Don't Think About Batman...


(Please note: the following blog was originally posted on my old blog Why Yes I Am Quite Random, Why Do You Ask?, a blog I can no longer access for some unknown reason. This is being put at the start of each blog I'm uploading, in case anyone comes across the blog and accuses me of plagiarism. This is explained further in my introduction blog.

The following was originally posted on Monday, January 23rd, 2012 at 8:31 pm)


So, I finally saw Sherlock Holmes: A Game Of Shadows over the weekend. After organizing to go see it with friends, all the stars aligned, plans were made and good times were had by all.

But you don't want to read about that. No, you want to know my thoughts on the movie (well, I assume that's the reason you're here. If you came here by accident, I apologize for boring you and leave you to go on your way). And while I was going to watch a couple more new releases before I got to this movie, as it turns out, one didn't show up at my local cinema and the other is only playing in the evenings, which is when I'm sleeping before I work (midnight starts, in case you were wondering), so they've been postponed for the moment, until I get a night off and possibly see the one in the evening or DVD release.
Alright, let's get started. You may recall a little while ago, I did a blog on the first Sherlock Holmes film, as I had rewatched it in anticipation for the sequel, and complimented the acting and having Sherlock be more action-orientated. Well, lets see if A Game Of Shadows can expand on that.

Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey, Jr.) is doing his best to thwart the plans of Professor James Moriarty (Jared Harris) but finds himself being outmaneuvered at every turn. But with attempts being made on the lives of his faithful-yet-snarky companion Dr. Watson (Jude Law), the good doctor's blushing new bride, Mary (Kelly Reilly) and Simza (Noomi Rapace), a woman targeted because her brother works for Moirarty, the game just became more serious and Sherlock must use all his wits to overcome the evil machinations of the man he dubs “the Napoleon of crime”.

Now, much as I hate to compare it to something Batman related (and yes, obviously I acknowledge that without Sherlock, Batman would have turned out drastically different), A Game Of Shadows reminds me of The Dark Knight, in the sense that the arch nemesis was saved for the sequel and hinted at with the ending of the first film. This was a great move, as it increases the tension and it allows the hero to establish themselves before taking on a greater threat, thus making the antagonist that much more impressive when they lock horns and adds an air of credibility (though unlike The Dark Knight, Sherlock had already been operating before the events of the first movie, though the film is our first to see how the Sherlock of this universe operates). Jared and Robert play off each other well, with neither one disrespecting the other, both in-character and as actors. Jared manages to be menacing while remaining calm and relatively sociable, rarely if ever raising his voice.
And he has own aide in Col. Sebastian Moran (Paul Anderson), who serves as a foil for Watson in his own way, both men being members of the army, though Moran was dishonourably discharged and became a mercenary for hire. Paul Anderson is great and I'm really hoping we haven't seen the last of Moran in this series.

If Jared and Paul were great additions in a villainous capacity, then Stephen Fry is a huge bonus for the heroic side. He's dry and witty, much like Stephen Fry offscreen. I imagine that in playing Mycroft Holmes, all Stephen has to do is put on clothes from a different era and he's good to go. Like Paul, I'm hoping for a return in future installments.

Much like the previous film, Robert and Jude were great and further developed their love-hate relationship onscreen, mostly based on Sherlock's interference in Watson's honeymoon (and seriously, don't hurt his wife or else your neck will suddenly have hands around it) and have great banter between them. Bickering like an old married couple, as the saying goes.

Noomi Rapace was certainly interesting. This is the first role I've seen her in (she'd be best known for originating the role of Lisbeth Salander in the original adaptations of the Millennium Trilogy, which I actually picked up before seeing the movie. Funny how these things work out) and I think she did pretty good. The character is impressive with her knives and I'm glad they didn't force a romance between her and Sherlock, but made her almost like a second sidekick, like Sherlock is The Doctor.

Wait... that would make sense, Moriarty does look like a form the Master would take. His plan is something the Master would instigate, given the time period. Sherlock is almost always right, has amazing abilities, has a companion, has eccentricities and quirks, survives the impossible time and time again, remains cool under pressure... maybe Sherlock IS The Doctor? Hmm. Must investigate further.

But seriously, she is a nice addition and isn't just slotted in to replace the void left by Rachel McAdams, who does appear in this, albeit briefly, but makes good use of the time she has.

Much like the previous film, the action is fast-paced and frantic. Good ol' fisticuffs, with some gunplay in the second half (and a cannon. Yeah, that scene is frickin' sweet) and Holmes once again narrating his moves internally (and he's not the only one...) makes for some interesting fight choreography. His timing is impeccable and his deductive skills while fighting remain ever sharp, noticing weakness he can exploit (like Batman! Damn it, I promised myself I wasn't going to do too many comparisons to Batman).

The dialogue too is as sharp as to be expected, with the mind games between Moriarty and Holmes the highlights. Dialogue is even lifted from the Holmes story The Final Problem, the story that first introduced Moriarty and thus, one of fiction's earliest supervillains was born. And the finale, without spoilers, also refers to that story.

There's really not much, if anything, to fault here. Guy Ritchie's done another solid film, with an excellent cast and crew. We may have to wait a while for the next one (and even longer for The Real Rock'N'Rolla, unfortunately) as Guy is possibly preparing to do his own take on The Man From U.N.C.L.E but I'm a (mostly) patient man. As for this film, a solid 4/5.

Tuesday, 20 March 2012

The Original Defective Detective


(Please note: the following blog was originally posted on my old blog Why Yes I Am Quite Random, Why Do You Ask?, a blog I can no longer access for some unknown reason. This is being put at the start of each blog I'm uploading, in case anyone comes across the blog and accuses me of plagiarism. This is explained further in my introduction blog.

The following was originally posted on Tuesday, January 10th, 2012 at 9:06 pm)

 
With Sherlock Holmes: A Game Of Shadows currently out in cinemas all over the world, I thought I'd rewatch the first movie to get myself pumped for the second film (not that I need it, I was already excited for it after the end of the first. But I'm getting ahead of myself).

Now, you can already guess what direction this review is leaning towards, but I can still break down what I liked and the plot details and such. Speaking of, there may be spoilers (well, as much as I can spoil anyway. Having a sequel means some things are kind of already spoiled, but since I didn't have a blog back when this movie came out, I couldn't talk about it during its initial run in cinemas).

I don't think I need to go into an origin story for Sherlock Holmes, he's one of the most well known pop culture creations. And when it comes to media adaptations, I wouldn't be surprised if he has the most or at least makes the top five (I do remember reading somewhere it was Dracula who had the most film adaptations or just different media adaptations in general, I may be wrong though). He's had a few comics, appeared in all sorts of TV shows and even had one set in the future, Sherlock Holmes In The 22nd Century (I never saw it so I can't say whether it worked or not), and if you wanted a movie marathon with just anything Holmes related, you'd probably have to take a week off work just to get through them all.

I must confess, I haven't read any of the actual stories yet, or seen many of the adaptations/different versions. One I have seen and highly recommend is Without A Clue, which goes with the idea that Watson is really the detective but hires a drunken actor to be Sherlock Holmes and sells the stories. And I am not just recommending it because Michael Caine plays Sherlock Holmes (though that wording alone should be enough to entice you).
But what worries me is, from what I know of the public perception of Sherlock Holmes, Watson is assumed to be a fat bumbling sidekick (think Porky Pig but human and minus the stutter) and Holmes is some infallible, uncorruptable, altruistic detective who constantly carries a pipe and says “Elementary, my dear Watson” (which he never says, by the way. He does use those terms, but never together). What this movie attempts to do is challenge that perception. And challenge it does.

Let's get into the story: Lord Blackwood (Mark Strong) has been apprehended by Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey, Jr.) and Dr. Watson (Jude Law) for the murders of several women. Several months after his arrest, Blackwood demands to see Holmes and warns him three more people will die and the world will be affected by the deaths. After seemingly being hung, Blackwood's plans are carried out and it's up to Holmes and Watson to prevent his grim prophecy from coming true.

Suffice it to say, I really enjoyed this movie. Guy Ritchie stepped out of his pet genre of gangster-drama for the first (successful) time and took a popular character and gave him a fresh spin (well, fresh compared to the public perception). He created a lively atmosphere, with an almost steampunkish feel. The battle at the end is an excellent piece of work, with the Tower Bridge serving as a wonderful place for the denouement.
Guy chooses to go with Sherlock being anti-social, kind of arrogant, and obsessive with his work (though not so much that he won't take notice of women) and part of why this works is Robert Downey, Jr.'s acting. I made a comment once to some friends of mine that it seemed like he was born to play the role of Tony Stark in Iron Man (and to this day, I still believe that to be partly true) but it's also entirely possible that this was the role he was made for. He cannot be flawed, he's that good. He portrays this Sherlock as being bored and looking for stimulation and when summarizing boring (to him) conclusions, his face conveys a look that says “Shoot me, that would be more fascinating an experience” which is what sells it. OK, the boredom thing isn't entirely new but the way RDJ does it, you could be convinced otherwise. When he's on the case, there's a twinkle in RDJ's eyes and you know awesomeness will soon follow.
Also of note, I do like the idea of Holmes as a combat strategist (the “fight club” scene, in which Holmes internally narrates the details he notices about the pugilist he's engaged in fisticuffs with) though I wonder if that was lifted from the books too. If it was, wouldn't surprise me, considering how the Holmes of the books was also fond of cocaine (you read that right. Those were strange times).

But where would Sherlock be without his snarky offsider, ready to add a human touch to the mechanical nature of Holmes' style of investigation? Now, I've never been much of a Jude Law fan, I always saw him as an English Leonardo DiCaprio: a pretty-boy who stares at the camera with a smug grin as if to say “I could say utter garbage like 'oodle banana fargle fingle-fangle' and you would not give a damn, you'd be undressing me with your eyes”. Like Leonardo, I have come to realize he DOES have talent, and for Law, it took Closer and the 2007 adaptation of Sleuth to prove it. But he's marvelous as Watson, looking dapper and proper, while also being a bad ass. He's more of a people person than Holmes, not just from his womanizing ways, but also in the fact that he's engaged to be married. There's an amusing scene in which Holmes meets Watson's bride-to-be, Mary (Kelly Reilly) and Holmes does his “detective work” on her and deduces some amazing truths based on small, inconsequential details, though getting her motivation wrong. Yeah, that shut you up, Holmes!
Portraying Watson as an equal is what sets him apart from the bumbling fool who seems to always be in awe of Holmes, regardless of the fact that being a doctor, he has abilities of his own!

Mary is not the only woman giving Holmes something to think about, though. Perennial thorn in Holmes' side (probably to him, anyway. Story-wise, she only appeared in one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's original works) Irene Adler (Rachel McAdams) turns up on orders from her employer to spur Holmes into action. I can see why RDJ wanted her in this film, she's really good. Conniving and charming, she and RDJ play off each other well and you can see the romantic subtext blossoming between them.

Mark Strong also turns in a solid performance as the antagonist, Lord Blackwood. He's always calm and collected and sure of himself, never hamming it up. He's like Holmes in a way, unfettered and methodical.
And he provides an interesting mystery, which is integral not just to a good Sherlock Holmes story but to, well, any mystery film. The film hints at a blending of the occult with science and making Blackwood look like a force from beyond the grave or at least in allegiance with the forces of darkness. And with the target being Parliament, its high stakes indeed.

But what of Holmes arch nemesis, one of the first and most well known arch nemesis, Professor Moriarty? Oh, like a good arch nemesis, he stays in the shadows, pulling the strings. But he will be seen, in Sherlock Holmes: A Game Of Shadows, which I intend on seeing sometime soon.
Until then, I have this rollicking action film to enjoy, a film I give 4/5 to.

P.S I have seen the new Sherlock series, the first season, and I really enjoyed it. Bring on the next set of episodes!